Alright friends, that was the weekend that used to be Week One of the finals but more accurately is the Qualifying & Elimination Final weekend, and my goodness what a weekend it was as David King's Premiership Pie wound up like the pie from American Pie with Fremantle and Brisbane getting carstrated on national television, but thankfully for them they both had mulligans so they'll play next weekend without their gonads, which can't be said for Carlton and the former Footscray.
Now, for the run down of all 4 finals:
It was shades of 1991 West Coast on Thursday night - Fremantle had 19 wins for the year, won the minor premiership, hadn't lost at home all year, but Hawthorn came to Perth with a plan and completely dismantled the Dockers in a 4-quarter defensive masterclass from Sam Mitchell's team, restricting Freo to their lowest score of the year (40 points), ensuring Wharfie Time was never deployed, the inclusion of Brandon Walker ended awfully as he did his ankle, and all told the Hawks won by 32 points, securing their first home Preliminary Final since 2014, and their first home final in Mitchell's tenure...
Random fact, Sam Mitchell has as many finals wins outside of Victoria in the last 3 seasons as Alan Joyce, Peter Schwab and Alastair Clarkson combined (3).
So the Hawks go through to another Prelim, while the Dockers get the Friday night Semi Final against Geelong, staring down one of the most brutal straight sets in modern history...
Still, that's the advantage of being Top 4, you do get the chance for a Qualifying Final mulligan, and Freo surely couldn't go any worse than they did on Thursday night.
Carlton matched Geelong for a half, and indeed they led at Half Time, but ultimately it was a case of fresh legs and sheer class winning out as Patrick Dangerfield became the oldest player to ever kick 5 goals in a Final (A record Gordon Coventry had held since 1937), and despite the Cats suffering a severe case of Brisbehinds in the last quarter, which did keep the margin far closer than it should've been, the Cats were comfortable winners by 33 points, making it 7 consecutive wins, and they look far from done.
Carlton's magic carpet ride under Josh Fraser is over, in what was the first time they've lost after leading at Half Time under Fraser, but from the shitpit they were in in May it was a superb turnaround, while the Cats have won an Elimination Final for the first time in Chris Scott's tenure, and they get a shot at a wounded Fremantle in Perth next week...
Random fact - WA is the only mainland state where Geelong haven't played a final until now, despite having played in a combined 9 finals against West Coast and Fremantle, which have all been in Victoria.
Despite all the crap spoken about the Qualifying Final in Sydney being a lay down for whoever played the Swans, Dean Cox's team obviously didn't believe a word of it, but obviously a few Brisbane Lions players did as they led with their chin and were promptly snotted by a superb Swans team, who produced the best win by any Swans team since the 2012 Grand Final when you consider the context leading into the game, with a 53-point spanking on the 2-time defending premiers, whose backline once again fluctuates between abhorrent (Especially in their games in Sydney this year), and superb whenever they want to be - The obvious downside being captain Callum Mills once again suffering a poorly timed injury in the Finals, and this time it's the most brutal one of them all being a suspected ACL tear.
Sydney/South Melbourne's highest score in a Final, and with Logan McDonald kicking a career-high 6 goals and Curnow + Papley 5 each, it was the first time any Swans team had 3 players kick 5+ goals since Round 18, 1933, and the first time it had happened in any final since Hawthorn in the 1988 Grand Final.
The Swans get to host a home Preliminary Final, after a series of events that will be talked about for years to come, while the Lions' premiership defence looks shaky for the 25th time in the last 3 years, but as I said previously they got a mulligan this week, just as they did last year, and until they're totally out of the finals they are the team to beat.
And tonight we saw the difference that good goalkicking can make in a close game, as the Bulldogs pissed away chances all night (Looking at you Naughton), even when they threatened to overrun Adelaide in the last quarter and were right in the game all night, while the Crows took their chances in front of goal, getting back on top in the last quarter with some textbook set shot goalkicking, plus Izak Rankine's deadset brilliant checkside goal that sealed the game, and ultimately after the report that Matthew Nicks could've faced the boot if the Crows lost, they instead won their first final under Nicks, their first finals win since the 2017 Preliminary Final, and Tex Walker got his great farewell to the Adelaide Oval as the Crows will go to Brisbane to play the Lions next Saturday night, while the Bulldogs season has come to end without ruining their record in single figure games.
9.14 to 14.6... GOOD KICKING IS GOOD FOOTBALL.
So all up, this weekend we've learned that Wildcard Weekend hasn't exactly helped the teams that played in Wildcard Weekend.
LOL of the Week
This week's nominees include The West Australian for once again jixning Fremantle, who still haven't won a final since that "Easy Home Finals Wins" backpage last year, Fremantle for once again pulling an almighty September Dockery, one of the worst ever recorded and adding chapter 99 to Nitro's post from Wednesday, the Lions for being so confident they'd win and getting absolutely pasted by the Swans....
But the LOL of the Week, rising to No.1 with a BULLET, is the artist formerly known as CROWMAN at the Crows-Bulldogs game tonight, but on further inspection, they have now been dubbed JIM CROW, for what is one of the more unfortunate face painting incidents of the 21st Century...
As Sgt Hartman once said in Full Metal Jacket...
MICHAEL VOSS MEMORIAL CARLTON OF THE WEEK
Congratulations, Fremantle!