Dark romance?
Smut?
Can't we just call it porn? Because that's what smut/dark romance actually is! Porn!
I don't understand why authors and readers can't just use the hentai/porn tag instead of pulling out of nowhere "dark romance" and "smut."
Besides, I don't understand either why many women act like dark romance/smut novels are something deep and thought-provoking... when they're just porn. Can't these female readers admit they're just as horny and perverted as the average anime anime fan?
I wanted to discuss about this very specific topic because of a dark romance novel called Morning Glory Milking Farm...
I can't believe I have written something like that...
This very specific novel is about... well... a woman who masturbates minotaurs (with very detailed descriptions to boot) to make creams for men's medicines... I guess...
Do you find this novel's premise extremely close to the plot of the naughtiest hentai doujin ever made?
Me too...
"Of course not! Dark romance/smut is deep, is thought-provoking, and is wholesome!! Your hentai anime bullshit is just mindless, misogynistic crap for the male gaze!!!"
Sigh...
Comments like this are very hypocrital, because many of the people who defends smut/dark romance with arguments like this one, are the same ones who judge others because of the kind of media they consume. As if smut/dark romance were very different from many hentai doujins... when that's not the case.
Besides, it's ironic how many of these defenders believe they're paragons of light and moral superiority when calling out "problematic" content, and even demanding for its removal. Because if we compare the average isekai anime (aka the average male power fantasy) with the average dark romance novel (aka the average female power fantasy), the average dark romance novel is much more extreme than the average isekai anime in terms of lewd content. What do you consider more outrageous?
- A story about a male character with no personality who gets an harem full of scantily clad tiddy waifus.
- A story about a female character being drugged and humilliated in +18 ways by a crowd.
Let's be honest, a fantasy anime with a female character wearing a bikini armor is nothing compared to many smut/dark romance novels about rape, humilliation, toxic relationships, and more NSFW stuff.
"Is there something wrong with women enjoying lewd stuff?"
No, not at all. Men and women can enjoy and read whatever they want, as long as they're not harming real people. Fiction is just that, fiction. There's nothing wrong with someone enjoying a hentai doujin, and there's nothing wrong with someone enjoying a dark romance novel. As long as nobody gets hurt IRL, they can do whatever they want.
What I do have a problem with is the, nonetheless, is with hypocrisy and arrongance.
I don't like how someone who brags about reading novels full of exploitation feel entitled to moralize and accuse others of being criminals just because they enjoy X anime or Y manga, or even worse, ask for the removal of the content you find "problematic."
I mean, if we're going to get moralistic over shady content in fiction (something I already consider stupid because, like I said before, we're talking about fictional stuff), then dark romance/smut novels should receive the same level of scrunity Berkserk and Evangelion get due to their respective "problematic" content, if not more.
Last but not least, here is a warning for pro-censorship people:
Hatred only creates more hatred, and if you treat other people with hatred, then those same people will treat you with hatred. If you want to ban and censor media that makes men happy, don't expect those same men to defend you when the things that make you happy get banned and censored.
Fun fact: I originally posted this on CharacterRant, and so many people got triggered in the comments and downvoted me (as well as downvoting people who agreed with me).
They literally proved every single point I have made right.