r/dynastybb • u/Demas_theHoopJunkie • Sep 16 '26
Draft Dynast Rookie Draft Pick Bust Anlaysis - 9 cat head to head
welcome in my fellow nba junkies... i'm back with an indepth dynasty nerd post for you boys... and i think this might be one of my best discussion starters yet.
my main dynasty league is 10 teams 25 man roster, 5 man taxi squad. We are entering year 7 and we have our 2026 rookie draft coming up in 2 weeks.
i was trying to negotiate selling norm powell to a team for pick 15. they said norm powell wasn't worth a young player in that tier. So i tried to show them that Norm is a top 100 9 cat player and should be for at least 3 more years. Some additional context, the team i was trying to trade with has never made the playoffs and they are finally ready to contend and stop the rebuild.
so as full time finance guy i got the work. I pulled up all of our rookie drafts (minus 2025) and i broke it down by round. I then ran a vlookup on each rookie draft pick against all the rosters to see which draft pick is no longer rostered.. aka picks that busted. I then looked at the players that were still rostered (aka picks that hit), and then i took the average dynasty 9 cat rank for each of them (again broken down by round). Here are the results and it is quite interesting.
The table shows how many bust there were by round.
- 1st round - has a 0% bust rate*** (with one exception - the weak 2024 class).
- average 9 cat rank of 1st round picks that stick = 95th in 9 cat
- 2nd Round- has an average of a 50% bust rate -
- average 9 cat rank of 2nd round picks that stick is 145th in 9 cat.
- 3rd round - has an average of 70% bust rate -
- average 9 cat rank of 3rd round picks that stick =204
the team said no to the trade but the data is on my side. pick 15 has a 50% chance of hitting and the average return will be a player ranked 145th.. Norman powell is around 70-90th in 9 cat pergame production.
i was offering them a guaranteed investment for one that has a very clear downside.
IF YOU TOOK THE TIME TO READ THIS FAR.. THANK YOU, YOUR ATTENTION AND TIME MEAN THE WORLD TO ME AND I WOULD LOVE FOR YOU TO SHARE YOUR ROOKIE DRAFTS.
IF YOU COMMENT SOME OF YOUR ROOKIE DRAFTS BELOW AND YOU ARE ABLE TO SEND SCREENSHOTS OF ALL THE TEAMS ROSTERS I WOULD LOVE TO RUN THE SAME ANALYSIS FOR YOUR LEAGE. DM me
| bust draft pick Analysis | Bust Pick Count | Round Bust % |
|---|---|---|
| 2021 1st round bust | 0 | 0% |
| 2021 2nd round bust | 6 | 60% |
| 2021 3rd round bust | 7 | 70% |
| 2022 1st round bust | 0 | 0% |
| 2022 2nd round bust | 6 | 60% |
| 2022 3rd round bust | 9 | 90% |
| 2023 1st round bust | 0 | 0% |
| 2023 2nd round bust | 3 | 30% |
| 2023 3rd round bust | 4 | 40% |
| 2024 1st round bust | 4 | 40% |
| 2024 2nd round bust | 5 | 50% |
| 2024 3rd round bust | 9 | 90% |