Hello,
I have around €10,000 in capital losses that I can offset against capital gains in next year’s tax return or in the following two tax years.
On the other hand, I hold shares in a fund that tracks the MSCI World and has an unrealized gain of 67.5%. In other words, I would need to sell around €25,000 worth of shares to realize €10,000 in capital gains and offset my losses. I wouldn’t sell them if it weren’t for the opportunity to offset those losses and save around €2,000 in taxes. My plan is to buy back the same fund as soon as possible (as I understand it, this is not a wash sale, as I am selling making profit).
There are a few risks I think I need to take into account:
Risk 1: While I’m out of the market with the €25,000, the market could go up (which would work against me, as I would be selling low and buying high) or it could go down (which would work in my favor, as I would be selling high and buying low).
Risk 2: My understanding is that the €2,000 in taxes will be withheld until I receive a refund during next year’s tax filing season, when I offset the gains against my losses. That €2,000 will be out of the market for several months.
How would you approach this situation?
Risk 1 could be mitigated by waiting longer for my fund shares to appreciate further. For example, if they had gained 100%, I would only need to sell €20,000 worth of shares instead of €25,000. The potential impact of market volatility would be smaller relative to the €2,000 tax saving, which is effectively guaranteed.
Risk 2 could be mitigated by selling at the end of the year rather than at the beginning. If I sell in December, the €2,000 in tax withheld could be tied up for at least six months, whereas if I sell in January, it could be tied up for as long as 18 months.
Would you use some kind of dollar-cost averaging (DCA) approach, selling and buying back blocks of fund shares worth, for example, €2,000 at a time?